1. Scope
1.1 This policy applies to all employees and workers of the council who are employed on permanent, temporary, fixed term or part time contracts and includes secondees, casual/sessional and bank workers. The policy also applies to Elected Members (see Section 7), and the council demands the same standards of conduct from contractors carrying out work for the council and/or working in council premises.
1.2 The policy applies in the workplace and in any work-related setting outside the workplace, e.g. business trips and work-related social events.
1.3 This policy and procedure supports North Ayrshire Council’s Equality Policy and reinforces the council’s commitment as an equal opportunities employer. It is also closely aligned to the principles of the council’s Code of Conduct and Disciplinary Rules.
2. Policy Statement
2.1 The council is committed to establishing a working environment in which all employees are treated with dignity and respect. The council expects its employees to adhere to the policy in their dealings with colleagues, Elected Members, agency workers, contractors, and the public.
2.2 The council requires all employees to treat one another with dignity, to respect each other's right to express opinions and not to harass, bully, victimise or otherwise subject another person to any types of demeaning behaviour.
2.3 This policy promotes the use of the informal procedure/mediation to resolve disputes between employees. However, where the informal procedure/mediation is not appropriate, or is not successful, there is a formal procedure which can be instigated.
3. Aims and Principles
3.1 The aim of this policy and associated procedures are to:
- Advance and communicate our zero tolerance of harassment, bullying, victimisation, and stalking, and encourage a culture of supporting employees to come forward with concerns.
- Emphasise the importance of dignity and respect at work and define the types of behaviour which are not acceptable.
- Provide arrangements whereby complaints can be investigated in a manner which recognises the sensitivity of the issues raised and the rights of everyone involved.
- Ensure that all allegations of any breach of the policy are responded to timeously, positively and with the utmost confidentiality.
- Recognise the harmful consequences, both for the organisation and individuals, of harassment, bullying, victimisation and stalking.
3.2 It should be understood that harassment, bullying, victimisation and stalking may also constitute a criminal offence. Managers who allow such behaviour to occur may also be held liable in law.
3.3 The parties involved in Dignity and Respect at Work incidents may experience feelings of stress, anxiety and alienation and it is important that they have access to counselling and support as necessary.
4. Explanation of terms
This section will provide an explanation of the terms used throughout this policy.
4.1 Harassment
4.1.1 In general terms harassment is unwanted conduct affecting the dignity, self-esteem, status or character of employees in the workplace. It may be related to sex, race, disability, age, religion or belief, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, sexual orientation or any other characteristic of the individual. It may also include a perceived characteristic of the individual. It may be persistent or an isolated incident.
4.1.2 Harassment can also be defined as improper, uninvited, unwarranted, offensive, humiliating, or degrading behaviour, practices or conduct, which may threaten a person’s job security, create an intimidating and stressful work environment or cause personal offence or injury. The most serious harassment can also be considered a criminal matter.
4.1.3 The definition of harassment also includes harassment by a third party. This includes clients, customers, contractors, and members of the public. The council will take all reasonable steps to prevent this.
4.1.4 The council also has a duty to prevent sexual harassment. All employees should undertake the mandatory e-learning course. Examples of harassment are contained in Appendix 2.
4.2 Bullying
4.2.1 Bullying is persistent unwelcome behaviour, mostly using unwarranted, invalid criticism, fault finding, exclusion, isolation, being singled out and treated differently, being shouted at, humiliated, or being excessively monitored. In the workplace, bullying can sometimes focus on distorted or fabricated allegations of under-performance.
4.2.2 Bullying is the intimidation or vilification of someone, through the misuse of power or position, offensive, intimidating, malicious or insulting behaviour which leaves the employee feeling upset, hurt, vulnerable or helpless.
4.2.3 Bullying and harassment can be experienced on a face-to-face basis, through written communications, e-mail or the telephone.
4.2.4 Examples of bullying are contained in Appendix 2.
4.3 Victimisation
4.3.1 Victimisation is when an individual is treated detrimentally because they have (or are believed to have) made a complaint or intend to make a complaint about discrimination, bullying or harassment or have (or are believed to have) given evidence or intend to give evidence relating to a complaint about discrimination, bullying or harassment.
4.3.2 Victimisation can also take place following the end of the employment relationship.
4.3.3 Examples of victimisation are contained in Appendix 2.
4.4 Stalking
4.4.1 Stalking is a crime, and consideration should be given to reporting incidents to the Police. It involves persistent and unwanted behaviour which can range from annoying to feeling that your life has been hijacked and your sense of safety and security is under threat.
4.4.2 Stalking is defined as two or more behaviours directed towards a victim which causes or could have caused the victim to suffer fear and alarm, whether intentionally or recklessly.
4.4.3 An employee who is experiencing stalking should report this in the first instance to Police Scotland, as stalking is a criminal offence. Employees may want to seek advice/support from their line manager.
4.4.4 If an employee discloses that they are experiencing stalking, their line manager should contact the Health and Safety Team to conduct a home working risk assessment and explore any additional supports. The Line Manager should also liaise with Legal Services for advice or the Home Security Team within Housing for further assistance.
4.4.5 Examples of stalking are contained in Appendix 2.
4.5 Effective Management and Supervision
4.5.1 Managers and supervisors require to manage their teams and team members. In doing so, it is valid and acceptable for them to:
- Issue reasonable instructions and expect them to be carried out
- Set and monitor expected standards of conduct and performance in line with internal council policies, procedures and relevant external regulation
- Use the council’s Dealing with Work Performance (Incapability) Policy and Procedure and Framework for Teacher Competence to manage concerns regarding employees’ ability to meet expected standards of performance
- Use the council’s Disciplinary Policy and Procedures to address issues of misconduct
- Use the council’s Wellbeing@Work (Supporting Attendance Policy) Policy and Procedures or Maximising Attendance (Teachers) to take actions in respect of the management and support of sickness absence
- Make constructive and fair critical comments about employees’ performance and behaviours as part of Supervision/Review meetings and Time to Talk or PRD discussions
4.5.2 Implementing these policies and procedures firmly and fairly does not in itself constitute an act of harassment, bullying or victimisation, although it is recognised that employees may have concerns while being managed within the parameters of council policies and procedures.
4.5.3 It is important to differentiate between firm but fair management (which is acceptable), and harassment, bullying and victimisation (which is not acceptable). It is in the interests of the council to ensure that a quality service is provided to customers and service users, and, to achieve this, managers and supervisors should be able to carry out their management duties without fear of complaints being raised against them.
4.5.4 In particular, ill-intentioned malicious, or vexatious complaints, or complaints designed to disrupt management processes or prevent or delay scrutiny of conduct or performance concerns, or as a counter for concerns being raised, investigated and addressed, will not be considered under these procedures, and may in themselves constitute harassment, bullying or victimisation and/or misconduct.
5. Making a Complaint
5.1 If you feel you may have been the target of harassment, bullying, victimisation and or stalking, or witness behaviour which you feel is threatening or intimidating, you will be encouraged and supported to take one (or more) of the local actions set out in the HR Guide: Dignity and Respect at Work Guidance for Employees.
5.2 If, having considered the guidance you feel more comfortable making a complaint in writing, you are of course free to do so, using the Dignity and Respect at Work Complaint Form.
6. Procedure for dealing with Complaints
This section will detail the procedure for dealing with a complaint.
6.1 Managing the complaint
6.1.1 These procedures are written as an individual complaining against another, but this should be read in the context that a complaint could also be one person complaining against a group of others or a group of persons complaining against one person.
6.1.2 It is very important that, as well as the complainant and alleged perpetrator, managers/supervisors maintain strict confidentiality to protect both the complainant and the alleged perpetrator. It must be emphasised that any breach of confidentiality will be treated very seriously.
6.1.3 Complaints will be investigated promptly and sensitively.
6.1.4 Where an employee is shown to have made malicious, unsubstantiated, or otherwise groundless complaints of harassment, bullying or victimisation, this may lead to disciplinary action being taken against the complainant. Similarly, where a complainant fails to follow the procedure or refuses to detail allegations when required to do so, this may result in the claim being declared invalid.
6.1.5 In relation to relation to clauses 6.2, 6.3 and 6.4 (below), the choice of which procedure to instigate in the first instance rests with the employee raising the complaint. Where the informal stage has been used and/or mediation has been explored and the offending behaviour continues the employee raising the complaint can then resort to the Formal Procedure.
6.1.6 It is emphasised that wherever possible, the Informal stage of the Procedure and or mediation should be used. However, it is recognised there will be instances where the seriousness of the complaint will warrant resort to the Formal Procedure without first going through the Informal Stage or mediation. Advice on this must be sought firstly from Human Resources (with or without the help or support as noted above) before proceeding.
6.2 Informal Procedure
6.2.1 An employee who considers that they have been subject to a breach of the policy should request the person(s) to cease the offending behaviour. The employee may not realise that their behaviour is inappropriate and sometimes a quiet conversation is all that is required to stop the offending behaviour.
6.2.2 Employees should, wherever possible use this route in the first instance. However, where it would be embarrassing or intimidating to approach the alleged perpetrator(s), then the employee should discuss the matter initially with their manager, or if that is not appropriate, discuss it with another line manager, or a member of Human Resources for advice. The employee may also wish to use the council’s confidential employee assistance programme for support.
6.2.3 Support to the employee may continue through their manager, another line manager or a HR representative accompanying the employee to a meeting with the alleged perpetrator to request that they cease the offending behaviour. It may be identified that mediation would be appropriate to try and resolve the situation (see section 6.3 below).
6.2.4 Where the employee speaks to the alleged perpetrator to cease the offending behaviour, they should record the action taken, for example in a notebook, diary.
6.3 Mediation
6.3.1 Mediation is a method of resolving disputes in an informal setting, and involves a neutral third party (which may be a line manager within the employing service, an HR Representative, Trade Union Representative or independent Manager appointed by the Service), with appropriate guidance and skills, bringing the two sides together (unless there are valid reasons for not doing so) with the aim of getting both parties to acknowledge concerns, accept the need to change behaviours and reach a mutual agreement on ground rules for interactions going forward. The HR Guide to Mediation provides advice, guidance, and practical examples of how to carry out mediation.
6.4 Formal Procedure
6.4.1 When the employee decides to take their complaint to the Formal Stage, the employee is required to detail their complaint in writing to their line Manager, setting out the grounds of the complaint, the steps taken under the Informal Procedure to resolve the issue and the outcome being sought to resolve the complaint.
6.4.2 The council’s Dignity and Respect at Work complaint form should be used to highlight the main issues wherever possible, although a complaint that is submitted as a letter should also be acted upon as described in this procedure. A copy of the completed form/letter must also be sent to the Senior Manager (People Services).
6.4.3 Following receipt of the complaint, the Manager should acknowledge receipt of the complaint and discuss the matter with the Senior Manager (People Services) or nominee. Where it is the Chief Executive who has received the complaint (6.4.1), they will then nominate an appropriate Executive Director to deal with the case.
6.4.4 The relevant Manager shall arrange a meeting with the employee (now referred to as “the complainant”) within five working days, where possible, to hear the complaint. An HR Adviser will be in attendance, for advice and guidance only.
6.4.5 The relevant Manager may agree a resolution with the complainant and take the necessary action. It should be noted, however, that no formal disciplinary action against an alleged perpetrator shall be taken without a formal investigation.
6.4.6 If the relevant Manager believes that the complaint warrants investigation, the complainant shall be advised accordingly and a formal investigation under this procedure will be arranged. The investigation procedure to be followed will be that set out under the Disciplinary Policy and Procedures, including rights to representation. If the Manager considers that no investigation is necessary, the complainant shall be advised accordingly in writing.
6.4.7 If the complainant is not satisfied with this decision, they have a right of appeal as set out in section 6.5.
6.4.8 Where the alleged perpetrator has line management responsibility for the complainant, a Senior Manager within the service must consider whether it is appropriate for the alleged perpetrator to be excluded from formal management meetings involving the complainant (for example Wellbeing@Work (Supporting Attendance Policy)) whilst the investigation and any subsequent action is still in progress. This is to ensure that actions taken against the complainant are seen to be conducted in an unbiased and transparent manner.
6.4.9 On the conclusion of the investigation, the findings of the investigation shall be submitted by the Investigating Officer in a report to the relevant Manager and the Senior Manager (People Services) or nominee to consider the appropriate action.
6.4.10 The relevant Manager will arrange a meeting with the complainant to advise them of the conclusions of the investigation and advise the complainant of any action to be taken and confirm in writing that the complaint has been supported (upheld), upheld in part or not upheld, and informed of their right to appeal. Please note that the complainant will not be provided with a copy of the Investigation Report into the alleged perpetrator, however they will be provided with a summary of reasons as to why the decision has been made.
6.4.11 The relevant Manager will also meet with the alleged perpetrator and advise them of the conclusions of the investigation. Where management’s action involves invoking the disciplinary procedure the alleged perpetrator must be advised at the same meeting. Where the outcome of the investigation is not upheld, the Manager may wish to allow the appeal period to expire before providing feedback to the alleged perpetrator. Where the outcome remains not upheld, the alleged perpetrator will not be provided with a copy of the report but will be provided with a summary of reasons as to why the decision has been made.
6.4.12 A separate investigation report will not normally be required as part of the disciplinary process. However, the alleged perpetrator should be provided with an opportunity under the disciplinary investigation to provide any further relevant information, having been provided at this stage (but not before) with written copies of the complaint, Investigation Report and other relevant information (for example witness statements).
6.5 Appeals
6.5.1 Where the complainant is dissatisfied with the outcome of the investigation or is dissatisfied with the decision of the relevant Manager not to have an investigation they have the right of appeal. The appeal shall be heard by a Panel comprising the Head of Service (People & ICT) (or nominee) and a Chief Officer (or nominee) not involved in the case. Where the complainant is employed within People Services, the Head of Democratic Services will replace the Head of Service (People & ICT).
6.5.2 The complainant shall submit the appeal in writing, where possible using the Dignity and Respect appeal form setting out their grounds of appeal and shall send the appeal to the Head of Service (People & ICT) no later than ten working days from receipt of written confirmation of the decision not to investigate the complaint or the investigation outcome.
6.5.3 The Head of Service (People & ICT) shall advise the complainant of the arrangements for the Appeal Hearing. The complainant must take all reasonable steps to attend the Hearing. The Appeal shall take place at the earliest possible date but not later than twenty working days following receipt of the appeal.
6.5.4 The complainant and their representative, if appropriate, together with the Manager/Senior Manager/Head of Service/appropriate Chief Officer who took the decision to uphold/partly uphold/not uphold the complaint shall attend the Appeal to present their case for consideration.
6.5.5 The Appeals Panel shall consider the appeal as presented by the complainant, representative and the manager. Where appropriate the Panel may propose independent mediation or conciliation. The Panel shall rule upon the complaint or where required, determine on a course of action. The decision of the Appeals Panel shall be binding on all parties.
6.5.6 The Head of Service (People & ICT) shall advise the complainant of the Appeal Panel’s decision within five working days.
7. Procedure for dealing with Complaints against Elected Members
7.1 The Ethical Standards in Public Life etc. (Scotland) Act 2000 establishes a Code of Conduct for Councillors regulating their behaviour. As part of the Code, there is set out a protocol dealing with relationships between members and officers. The protocol is set out in Annex C to the Code.
7.2 In the event that a complainant considers that they have been harassed, bullied, victimised, stalked, or subjected to demeaning behaviour by an Elected Member, a complaint should be submitted in writing to their Executive Director or appropriate Chief Officer, who will thereafter meet with the complainant and determine the substance of the claim and what action, if any should be taken.
7.3 In all cases, every effort will be made to resolve the matter in accordance with the Informal Procedure, but if the complaint cannot be resolved, it will be passed to the Chief Executive or nominated representative for further action, which action may, if the circumstances warrant, include referral to the Standards Commission for investigation.
8. Employee support and training
8.1 It is recognised that an employee who is subjected to harassment, bullying and victimisation at work may suffer emotional or psychological reactions to their experiences. The council regards the use of counselling as a positive benefit and it is considered essential, therefore, that management responds in a sympathetic and supportive manner.
8.2 In all cases, counselling should be offered to the employee who has been subjected to the harassment, bullying or victimisation through the council’s Employee Assistance Programme, other external agencies or appropriate individuals. The employee can contact the EAP 24 hours a day to make arrangements for counselling. Where the employee has difficulty with this, they should contact Human Resources. Reasonable time off with pay shall be given to the employee in such cases.
8.3 An employee who is either alleged to have or has been shown to have breached the Dignity at Work policy may also suffer emotional or psychological reactions to the experience and should also be offered counselling or other intervention as appropriate to remedy the bullying, harassing or victimising behaviours displayed. Managers with the help of Human Resources must carefully assess the requirements in each case and where it is deemed that some intervention is required; Human Resources will make the necessary arrangements. Reasonable time off with pay shall be given to the employee in such cases.
9. Monitoring of Policy and Procedures
9.1 A record of formal complaints under this procedure will be maintained confidentially on the council’s HR/Payroll system and will be used to monitor the number and nature of formal complaints submitted.
Appendix 1 - definition of terms
Protected characteristics
The Equality Act 2010 sets out characteristics protected from discrimination:
- age
- disability
- gender reassignment
- marriage and civil partnership
- pregnancy and maternity
- race
- religion or belief
- sex
- sexual orientation
Appendix 2 - Examples of Harassment, Bullying, Victimisation and Stalking
The following are examples of the types of behaviour associated with Harassment, Bullying, Victimisation and Stalking. This is not an exhaustive list.
General Harassment
- Jokes, comments, ridicule, sectarian songs
- Social media posts, text messages, emails, notices, badges or posters
- Gesturing, posturing or threatening poses or obscene gestures
- Making comments about job security without foundation
- Deliberately making constant criticism
- Ridiculing someone – picking on them or putting them down in front of colleagues
Sexual Harassment
- Unnecessary touching or unwanted physical contact
- Lewd, suggestive remarks or over-familiar behaviour
- Any behaviour which creates an offensive, threatening or intimidating atmosphere, for example the use of language of a sexual nature, display or circulation of sexually suggestive material
Sex Orientation-Based Harassment
- Engaging in unwanted conduct because of a person’s gender, for example ridiculing the person because the person is going through gender re-assignment
- Homophobic, biphobic and/or transphobic language, jokes or banter that is negative or disrespectful of, or that perpetuates stereotypes about lesbian, gay, bisexual or trans people
Racial Harassment
- Abusive language, mockery and racist jokes
- Patronising remarks, racial name calling or racist graffiti
- Display or circulation of racially offensive material
- Subjecting the employee to physical abuse
Harassment by a third party
All areas covered by general harassment, but the act is being committed by a third party not employed or contracted by the council.
Bullying
- Intimidation by physical abuse or threats of abuse, aggression, threats, shouting or obscenities
- Persistent unwarranted criticism
- Undermining a person’s authority
- Overbearing supervision or any other misuse of power or position
Victimisation
- Labelling an employee as “a troublemaker”
- Isolation or exclusion from workplace activities
- Spreading malicious rumours or insulting someone
- Subjecting an employee to a detriment, such as demotion, forfeiture of opportunities for promotion, training, or dismissal due to a protected category
Stalking
- Persistent unwanted personal comments or messages, whether seemingly flattering or nasty
- Following someone within or outside work
- Persistent threatening behaviour by words, actions, or symbolic gestures
Appendix 3 - Levels of Authority
The information below sets out the levels of authority for dealing with Dignity and Respect at Work Complaints.
Alleged Harasser: Manager to Hear Complaint
Executive Director: Chief Executive
Senior Manager/Head of Service: Executive Director
Line Manager: Senior Manager/Head of Service
Any other employee: Line Manager
Appendix 4 - Sources of support
Internal North Ayrshire Council contacts:
- Employee Assistance Programme (0800 882 4102, NACEAP - organisation code)
- Wellbeing Warriors
- HR Team (01294 324669, HROperationsTeam@north-ayrshire.gov.uk)
- Health and Safety Team (01294 324737, CorporateHealthandSafety@north-ayrshire.gov.uk)
Women's Aid offices:
- North Ayrshire Women's Aid (01294 602424)
- South Ayrshire Women's Aid (01294 266482)
- East Ayrshire Women's Aid (01563 536001)
- Cumnock and Doon Valley Women's Aid (01290 423434)
- Women's Centre, Kilmarnock (01563 544807)
If preferred for Black and Minority Women:
Support for men experiencing domestic abuse:
- Men's advice line (0808 801 0327, info@mensadviceline.org.uk)
- Respect Phone Line (0808 802 4040, info@respectphoneline.org.uk)
External resources:
Local support:
- Ayrshire Samaritans (116 123 (UK))
- North Ayrshire Victim Support - 01294 277040 (Monday to Friday, 10am to 2pm) or 0345 603 9213 (Monday to Friday, 8am to 8pm)
National Support:
- Suzy Lamplugh Trust
- National Stalking Helpline (0808 802 0300)
- Action Against Stalking (support@actionagainststalking.org)
- Rape Crisis Scotland (08088 01 03 02, 6pm to midnight, seven days a week)
- Bullying Helpline (0845 22 55 787)
- Respect Me (Scotland's Anti-Bullying Service)
- Enable Scotland (0300 0200 101)
- Shelter Scotland (0808 800 4444)
National Mental Health Support:
- Breathing Space (0800 83 85 87)
- SAMH (Scottish Association for Mental Health) (0141 530 1000)
Translate